Wednesday, October 4, 2023

The Whitewashing of Soul Singer James Brown.

August 4, 2014 by  
Filed under Ent., Music, News, Opinion, Weekly Columns

Like Love Haha Wow Sad Angry

( There were several meetings. Eight white men and two white women. Was this a meeting of the Mormon Glee Club? The New White Citizens Council? Perhaps a Klan meeting? No. That meeting was the creative team for the new James Brown movie, “Get On Up.”

Welcome to post-racial Hollywood where if you host a fundraiser for Barack Obama, you’re freed of the burden of hiring black writers. And where a rich white producer can jokingly declare, “I’m black.”

Indeed, all the producers, writers, and the director of the James Brown movie are white. No black people were hired until a few weeks before the cameras started rolling, the actors. In fact, several of the people involved in this whitewash are British. The Brits have a fetish for black projects.

This is the Donald Sterling message: don’t bring them to the game. There are over fifty black iconic biopics and black-themed movies in development in Hollywood, including multiple Richard Pryor projects,2014-JamesBrown-Say-It-Loud-Im-Black-and-Im-Proud five Martin Luther King projects, multiple Marvin Gaye projects, and civil rights projects, and only one or two have an African American writer. Our entire history has been given over to white writers.

When the late David Wolper was producing “Roots” thirty-something years ago, he hired no black writers. When asked why, he was quoted as saying: “They’re too close to the material.” I guess we’re still too close.

This Hollywood apartheid against the African American writer could be understood if the writers being hired were of such quality as to be beyond reproach artistically. With rare exception, that is not the case. Sift through the morass, and you’ll find a group of hacks, insiders, and drinking buddies. The executives are trading our icons around like baseball cards.

How do these insiders, pals of the executives, become experts on black culture overnight? Wikipedia. In case you didn’t know, the entire black experience is on Wikipedia. Here is a typical day in Hollywood. Agent calls a writer, tells him he got him an interview for “this black guy who was really important.” The writer says cool, goes to the wiki pages, memorizes them, takes the meeting and wings his “knowledge” of the black icon. That’s it. He gets the job.

You see, the first thing people do in this town before hiring someone is look in the mirror. What I see in front of me is beauty, brains, and competence, Oh, and hipness. Yep, that’s who I’m gonna hire: me!

If ever a project required black creative involvement, it was this one. James Brown was the blackest entertainer in the history of America. The blackest. There was nothing integrationist about his art, at all. He never tried to crossover. You had to come to him. He was iconic and not just musically.

And yet, where did producer Brian Grazer hire to embody this blackest of black men? Three white writers, two of them from England. Then more producers were added, all white, and a white director, who has said that he sees this as a movie about singing and dancing. Bingo. Now we’re ready to make a black movie. It doesn’t matter a bit that one of the producers is a famous rock star who played with Brown a few times and lifted some of his moves. James Brown belongs to us, the black masses, and for us to be excluded from the creative team that made this movie is an obscenity. I’m aware that Spike Lee was involved briefly, but the finished product looks like a Mitt Romney family reunion.

Let me tell you who James Brown was, really, not the Wikipedia James Brown.

He was a civil rights icon. Put James in the pantheon of the most impactful black men of the 20th century, and he would not be out of place. How can I make such an assertion? One song: “I’m Black and I’m Proud.”

Before that song, if you wanted to start a fight with a man of color, all one had to do was call him black. Up until the mid-sixties, we were trying define ourselves: not colored anymore, now Negro. But black was not something we called ourselves. And along comes this little man and proudly states, “I’m black and I’m proud!” He took the thing that the oppressor used to bludgeon us and made it a weapon of pride for us.

That song caught on like wildfire. One day, our heads were down, the next day, our heads were held high, proud of who we were. We had all these groups, civil rights groups, Muslims, Panthers, but it was JB who gave us our swagger. That song lifted up an entire race! He put us on his back and carried us. Dr. King gave us our rights. JB gave us our dignity. Civil rights icon? You better believe it.

When that song came on the radio, cars stopped in the street. People turned up their radios, came out of their houses, and sang along with it; radio stations put it in a loop and played it for hours. The next day people greeted each other with “Hello, black man!” “My black brother.” JB made black beautiful overnight.

But the focus of this movie is singing and dancing. When we are kept out of the room, that is what you end up with, a pale Wikified imitation of what a great man was.

And yet, if someone decided to do the Gloria Steinem story, you better believe women would be involved; they’d have to be. Can you fathom ten men sitting in a room, male writers, directors, and producers all staring at their navels grunting: “I am woman, hear me roar“? But that won’t happen because people in this town respect women.

It’s too late to save JB, but maybe there’s hope to save the other icons from the Wiki-fueled humiliation of having their stories told by people who have no organic connection to us or our struggle.

Written By Gregory Allen Howard

Official website;



2 Responses to “The Whitewashing of Soul Singer James Brown.”
  1. Glenn Towery says:

    Hollywood is the most racist icon left in America and the creation of the James Brown so-called biopic is a perfect example. Even when a Black writer or producer is brought in to helm or create a project such as this one, the pressure for them to conform to the view of the white superstructure of Hollywood is impossible for them to escape. The major rule in Hollywood is that at the end of the day. No matter what a Black man or woman has accomplished, or other person of color, they are still second class citizens in a powerful white society.

    The only way to deal with what Hollywood is and continues to be is to dismantle it. Hollywood as we know it was born from racism. Its first true iconic directors were avowed racists. It has never allowed other races of people to be the heroes and heroines through writing, producing, directing and/or acting through the creation of their own cultures movies. Dismantle Hollywood, and you will discover many of the prejudices that exist today in America will subside and pass away without Hollywood’s continual subliminal reinforcements. There is so much to be said here that is relevant to how America views its self its citizens of color. Unfortunately America’s psyche is often informed through the prism of the lens of others who seek to make a dollar, uplift their own stories, and exploit the stories of other cultures by denying those cultures any seat at the table when they tel their iconic stories.

    We must begin again if ever we are to have fairness and loosen the grip on prejudice for filmmakers in America. If not all of our future films will be like “James Brown” or “Django Unchained” ugh!

  2. James Davis says:

    Sounds like you are saying, “The white guys have all the fun, while we blacks are left out in the cold.” It’s true bro, the white guys are having all the fun, creating, producing, and building things. You know why? Because they have and are willing to put up the “risk capital necessary to bring a project like the James Brown movie into being.” Once we are able to acquire the “same risk capital,” we will be able to do the same thing. But, first brother, we must realize “risk capital” is the missing link. Once realizng that, as any wise person would do, chart a logical course to obtain it. This ain’t rocket science. We don’t have because we are not adjusting our thinking processes which would allow us to coalesce around a plan to obtain that we so dearly desire the means to have fun, creating, producing and building things. Again,it ain’t rocket science! To get that which you desire simply takes a plan.

Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!