(ThyBlackMan.com) I guess I’m going to have to retrace my steps, yet again. Last week I reprise an article on Zionism (Maybe I’m Dumb, but Could Somebody Please Tell Me the Difference Between Zionism and Racism?). Due to a response to the article by a young Black man the first time it ran, I found it necessary to write a follow-up article the following week. That seems to be necessary once again:
.
I try to Avoid addressing the same issue in consecutive columns – that’s my only defense against my natural tendency to be tedious and predictable. But this past weekend a young man, let’s call him Rob, came up to me and said, “Brother, I got to give you props – you really stuck it to those damn Jews last week.” As soon as the words came out of his mouth I knew I had to clarify my message by revisiting the issue of Zionism. I didn’t have the time, at that moment, to stand there in front of the store and explain to the young man that my article wasn’t against Jews, but on the other hand, I wanted to make sure that he understood the distinction between hating a philosophy, and hating a people. So I asked the young man to be sure to pickup the following week’s paper because I was going to write an article especially, and specifically, for him. So Rob, as promised, this one’s for you – and I sincerely hope that God gives me the skill to make my point.
.
Rob, while my last article had to do with a segment of Judaism, it wasn’t intended as a diatribe against Jews. I’m not against Jews, or any other group of people. I’m against various behaviors.
.
It would be a pity to go through the pain and suffering that Black people have experience in America and not come out the other end with at least some measure of wisdom. One would think that we would have learned through the blood, sweat, and tears that we’ve shed, that trying to paint any group of people with the same broad brush, whether it’s to say that they’re all good, or they’re all bad, is not only the height of stupidity, but is the very mindset that has caused Black people so much misery here in America. How can I claim to detest racism, only to turn around an embrace that very same ignorant philosophy?
.
No, I’m not against Jews, I’m against the injustice of Zionism – a philosophy which dictates that one group of people are entitled to the land of another by virtue of their religious beliefs alone. But while I argue passionately that Zionism is a gross and unjust philosophy, I always keep in mind that all Jews are not Zionists. In fact, many Jews are more adamantly opposed to Zionism than non-Jews.
.
It’s important to recognize that fact, because efficient thought requires that we always recognize subtle distinctions. While knowledge is power, knowledge can only yield its power when combined with the wisdom of truth. Evident of that is the fact that one of the most prolific problems that we have in this vast world filled with knowledge, is our tendency to circumvent that knowledge through thinking with our brain stems. Instead using our higher cognitive abilities and taking the time to be precise in our thinking, we find it easier to lob preconceived generalizations at every problem – and more often than not, those generalizations cater to the very darkest side of our nature. Look at what we’re doing with our knowledge in the Middle East. Instead of using that knowledge to enhance the quality of life for all of humanity, we’re using it to spread death and destruction around the entire world.
.
We’ve got to learn to stop thinking in terms of Black and White, Jew and Gentile, or whether a person is Gay or Straight. As long as we think in those terms and continue to antagonize one another, we sabotage every opportunity to form coalitions to fight for our common good. That’s why people like Bush, Cheney, and much of the GOP crowd thrive in a hostile environment. They love keeping us ignorant, because ignorance keeps us divided, and that very division allow them to step in and conquer all of our hopes and dreams as a people. It is a must, therefore, that we develop the wisdom to understand that there are only two kinds of people in this world – good people, and bad people.
.
Now, I’m not suggesting that Black people forget their history and engage in a rousing chorus of Kumbaya, that would be fool hearty. But it behooves Black people to not only understand, but remember, that while malevolent White men did indeed place us in shackles, it was malevolent Black men who made us available to be shackled. We must also recognize that we commit a gross injustice by forgetting the sacrifice, and the families, of the thousands of White men of good character who gave their lives to unlock those shackles.
.
So while we witness the horror and atrocities that the state of Israel is committing against the Palestinian people and we lean toward condemning all Jews, we must keep in mind men like Joel Elias Spingarn, also a Jew, and a prominent literary figure of his time. He not only gave great support to the Harlem Renaissance, but helped W.E.B. DuBois to establish the NAACP as a driving force for change in America. Spingarn also established the Spingarn Medal in 1913 – and to this day it’s awarded annually for Excellence in African American Achievement. So as we’re formulating our opinions about Jews, we should remember this man and many others who made great contributions to the African American people.
.
Spingarn was Chairman of the Board of the NAACP from 1913 until his death in 1939. We should also keep in mind that during that period the NAACP board was predominantly Jewish – W.E.B. DuBois was the only Black man on the Board of Directors. In fact, the NAACP didn’t elect its first Black president until 1975. Think about that.
.
But it’s become less than politically correct to bring up issues such as these – probably because many of us are afraid of becoming associated with Black opportunist, turncoats, and White apologists like Clarence Thomas, Alan Keyes, Larry Elder, and the like. But it’s important that we keep these facts in mind and pass them down as part of our history. Facts such as these represent valuable knowledge to our youth. It’s a source of knowledge to young people that says – as the three misguided Black men mentioned above clearly atest – everybody that looks like you is not your brother, and conversely, everybody that doesn’t look like you is not your enemy.
.
That’s an invaluable lesson, not only for Black people, but for all of America, because we will never truly overcome until all people of good faith come together as a coalition – and that will never happen until we begin to recognize that true brotherhood is not of the skin, but of the soul.
Yes, Jews, Zionism, and the Stupidity of Bigotry.
Staff Writer; Eric L. Wattree
More thought provoking articles feel free to visit; The Wattree Chronicle.
What’s your reaction?
Love0
Sad0
Happy0
Sleepy0
Angry0
Dead0
Wink0
@Delfina….Meh old narratives still… the information you provide reminds me of the futile attempt to justify a sin. Its a slippery slope and although you provide plenty of information regarding the historical tit for tat which is going on in Israel. When Hamas came into existence they were so broke that those “rockets” didn’t have any type of GPS so they landed where ever whenever and sometimes killed there own people. Israel is backed militarily by the U.S. Your opponent wasn’t Russia… come on. We got gangs in the USA better armed. Lets not act like everyone (both sides) in Israel is Ghandi or something.
Its Mandatory in Israel to join the military. Poor Philosophy for people who seek peace. War for Peace doesn’t work. Moving people out there homes they mortgaged and giving them away…. sounds like that would start a fight in any hood. You just can’t justify the sin…..
Are we mad as a society at Blacks early on in slavery for revolting against the oppressor. (Haiti) No matter the justification that the master held…its not right. And How could we be mad at slaves for wanting freedom.
So how could the outside world look in at Palestinians and there aggression and say its in no way shape or form justified….???
Interesting Mr. Delfina… to the victor goes the spoils and control of the narrative is important. Israel suppresses the oppositions point of view.
You have listed several instances in which Palestinians are deserving in there punishment from Israel…But!! What Started the Beef???
What would you do to reclaim the home you were living in now….??
As if…the people wouldn’t object.
Retaliation is part of the cycle…
Israel wants the land it deems HOLY…with blood shed you want to reclaim it… interesting GOD is LOVE, don’t justify the sin and label it as necessary… God made this Universe, Earth, etc…and These Childlike minds think Israel is big enough (its the size of New Hampshire…sheesh)for God??. Talk about the blind leading the blind….
God is God…and people attach child like philosophies and say he will be back and only in this one city. My God is Omnipresent yours sounds like he needs a realestate agent. And the land to me isn’t holy, the people are, the land is rock, sand, and earth,… last I checked God said we were his most prized possession…. Not a coat, car, or piece of land by the beach…
Who’s right or wrong….if the debate is childish we are wasting time with the low hanging fruit….
For the Record…when the Church was expelling Jews around 711 or something…it was the Muslims who came to the rescue of the Jew and let them live peacefully…. Even in Cannan….
No you don’t have to walk through the city to read a book about the history… I didn’t need to see a dinosaur walking around 1 million years ago to know they were big as ish…. look at the bones, the evidence.
Those bones in Israel tell a story… no life is wasted…or a waste…
its 2014 and there has never been so much information at your finger tips… use it! A trip to physically walk the land would be cool.
But I live in the USA, we are something like the biggest melting pot. I here stories from S. America, to Africa, Europe and if you wanna hear the pulse of the Middle East come to the hood and go to the corner store…
Its like the barbershop for black people…or the water cooler at the office… good uncensored/tainted/information
It’s illegal to operate a church in Saudi Arabia. So do you equally criticize the 50 Muslims states surrounding Israel for allowing the Muslim religion – and ONLY the Muslim religion – to be the official law of the land?
This is from: http://observer.com/2013/12/the-anti-semitic-stench-of-pink-floyd/ An answer to Roger Waters. I am copying it and pasting it because I found it so explaining and clearifying in a very short length. I hope you read it and start getting your records straight, because you are basing yourself on SUCH false information that I can’t even imagnie from which manipulated source you get your info… Your views on judaism are really distorted and twisted.
“After the Arabs launched another war of annihilation against Israel in 1967, the Jews miraculously defeated four invading Arab armies and conquered huge tracts of land. Rather than practicing any kind of ethnic cleansing, Israel gave back the entire Sinai Peninsula—an area three times the size of Israel—to Egypt in exchange for a peace treaty and announced that it would leave the Arabs and the Muslim Waqf in charge of the holiest site in all of Judaism, the Temple Mount. This act of accommodation has no precedent in the history of the world.
Still, Arafat’s PLO, with its declared intention of armed struggle and destroying the Zionist presence, launched terrorist outrages like the 1970 Avivim school bus massacre and the 1974 Ma’alot school massacre. Despite this, Israel never relinquished its hope that Arab leaders who were sincere about peace might arise.
In 2005, Israel voluntarily withdrew from all of Gaza. Its reward? Hamas, with its genocidal charter against Israel, was voted into power and almost immediately began launching thousands of rockets into Israel, targeting homes, schools and buses filled with children.
Muslims have every right to expect that Jews in general, and rabbis in particular, similarly condemn any acts of violence intentionally directed at any Arab civilian. We are all equally children of one God.
But Hamas is motivated not by Palestinian freedom but by hatred of Jews. Hamas’ charter continues to call for genocide against Israel and the Jewish people: “The Day of Judgment will not come until Muslims fight the Jews, when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say, ‘O Muslims … there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him.’”
When Hamas came to power in 2006, they channeled the billions they received as the world’s largest per capita recipients of international foreign aid into rockets rather than hospitals, bombs rather than universities. And they intentionally launch their rockets from nurseries and schools rendering the innocent Palestinian population into human shields, not surprising for an organization that regularly murders Palestinian homosexuals under the false accusation of collaboration and engages in honor killings of young Palestinian women whose only crime is to have a boyfriend.”
Read more at http://observer.com/2013/12/the-anti-semitic-stench-of-pink-floyd/#ixzz2ty10UWXH
Follow us: @newyorkobserver on Twitter | newyorkobserver on Facebook
Most palestinians do not want to share a state with us. Maybe if you had ever talked to a real person living in Palestine, then you would know. Israeli arabs do want to stay in Israel even if there was a Palestinian state one day. Why do you think is that? Because they are willing to live in an “apartheid state” as you like to call it? I don’t think so. They just want to live in a democratic country where they can live in peace and complain about things and not get murdered for it. Yes, Moses was actually probably MOSE, an egyptian soldier who preached the one and only God and chose a group of different people from different origins who came to Egypt and became their political and spiritual leader, making them , through the course of centuries, embrace a one and only God, as opposing to paganism which was characteristic of the time. Judaism is not an exclusive club the way you are making it to be. Something for “special and chosen” people. It is for everyone who makes the CHOICE to be jewish. That is, if you are born to a jewish mother and decide to be jewish, or, if not having been born from a jewish mother, you DECIDE to become jewish. NO ONE who makes the true decision to become jewish can be denied so.
What does me being white or black make any difference? I am not competing with you over who suffered more through history, blacks or jews. It is not a contest. But trust me, I am speaking from my heart, I know what you went through. I don’t need to explain what my family went through and I won’t, this is not a pity contest. We are two grown-ups , and having suffered doesn’t make you a better person. Only, if your heart is big enough, maybe it makes you understand people more. It makes you more compassionate in the best of cases. Jews have been expelled, tortured, killed through history in Europe for centuries. You need to get your info right, please. The only way we can continue to exist is to have a state. Jews were living in Israel before 1948 and before Zionism, as well as arabs. When the UN partition came, they and other 6 arab countries decided they didn’t want a jew neighboor. And the war hasn’t stopped since. Do you think it doesn’t hurt me what goes on in Israel with the palestinians? do you think it doesn’t break my heart that some of them live in such sub-human conditions? I am not here to defend every decision Israel has made. I believe we, as well as them, deserve to live in peace. But please, do notice, that as well as palestinian children, jewish children have dies too from this war over the past years. Why do you only notice the victims on the palestine side? DON’T WE HAVE THE SAME RIGHT TO LIVE? DON’T WE????????
@delfina Hey…You don’t hate Palestinians?? Are you sure. You just want them separated from the masses and split into two separate states. Great are you giving them the nice beach land to keep?? You don’t hate them in the classical sense…you just don’t want them in your neighborhood. Bigot maybe?? God’s biggest Commandment to man is to love. That philosophy you preach, was preached in Germany and America and South Africa to name a few places. Tell me how that worked out for the people who “needed to move”. Separate but equal…meh
Travels not needed to put holes in a weak philosophy… childish we are….
Delfina…you gotta step out your box a little. Your philosophy is one that is closed and yes exclusive…not everybody can join that club you preach of… new members can join but only certain ones & types. I say let everybody join the party.
Hey I say if your from the Middle East, you shouldn’t be kicked out of your neighborhood so an Eastern European can move in to primo realestate. Blacks and Palestinians share a lot in common. Its gotta suck if your a Palestinian…even when you do let off a bomb…your opponents owns a airforce it didn’t even have to pay for???
Delfina calm down, I know you read up on History, sad you don’t go further back then the Torah. Early Egpyt is a start… Hope you don’t think the name Moses is Hebrew or Jewish… Research the Etymology of the name Moses…then search Hyksos invade Egpyt…
No one is trying to be an Anti Semite…but you clearly lack respect for adversity. Which is why you lack thicker skin. At anytime you can take that lil hat off….for me and Black America its not like I can Bleach and Hide. You can die your hair blonde or perm ya hair. You Can Transform. Most of the time we don’t even know who is and isn’t a Jew…be serious
Unless you are groomed and dress in Orthodox manner who knows your heritage… You not even thought about by black America. Your white…sorry in black America you just are.
Yea right…you got it so bad…yea right 1930s pretty bad. Blacks timeline since 16th-17th CENTURY…lil rougher. This isn’t a good place to shed your tears. Meh?
I tell you what…if I was GOD…I made man & woman that’s who I chose…not a small subset of less than 1%. The 1% is not the Chosen ones…old tired narrative to me. I love everyone.
Parallel dynamic in the debate…
Me and my sister always fight over my mother’s attention and who is the darling in her eyes. Sometimes she rats me out to look good…sometimes I tell her since I’m the “BABY” I will always be Mom’s Favorite…
Nothing wrong with wanting to be the Favorite but don’t let it go to your head….
Please watch this. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sDXeUhUpHYY
” there are only two kinds of people in this world – good people, and bad people. ” In this sentence you are doing the exact thing that you “claim” to criticize through the whole article. If you study a little bit of judaism (you must, before you talk on any of these subjects, study judaism, and study the islam too to start understanding something, as well as the history of both peoples), you will learn that people are not their actions. People don’t incarnate their actions. That menas, this world is not made up of good people or bad people. Have you ever met anyone who was only good, or completely bad? Not because they don’t exist other than in your mind, full of stereotypes. People are just people, who every day in their life get a chance to do GOOD or to do WRONG. It is a CHOICE, not destiny. EVERYDAY EACH ONE OF US HAS A CHANCE TO DO GOOD OR TO DO BAD. If we chose “good”, that doesn’t make you a GOOD PERSON, it jus makes you a PERSON WHO TODAY CHOSE TO DO THE RIGHT THING. And the same goes for wrong. The world is NOT black and white, good and evil, always dual, the world is much more complicated than you seem to wish it would be.
You are absolutely ignorant. You should read a lot more before you even mention de word ZIONISM . you have no fucking clue what you are talking about. It’s about a people struggling for survival. Nothing to do with stealing land from another people because of religion. You are very ignorant and your ignorance is leading you to some serios racism. Anti-zionism is the new form of anti-semitism. Please study a little bit more on the subject before you open your mouth, you disrespectful man. I am jewish and a zionist and I don’t hate palestinians, I want us and them to live in peace in two separate states. You don’t have a clue what you are talking about. Go to university, hear some interesting proffesors talking, go read some books, TRAVEL TO ISRAEL AND PALESTINE FOR GOD’S SAKE!!!!!! LEAVE YOUR KEY-BOARD AND ALL YOUR PREJUDICE BEHIND YOU AND GET OUT TO TO THE WORLD FOR SOME REAL INFORMATION!!!!
@ERIC
YOUR knowledge of this subject is just as limited as it is on politics.
LET me help you my brother ; ZIONISM is the political expression of JUDAISM; the two are not mutually exclusive they are both sides of the same coin.
JUST recently the SEPHARIC ultra orthodox chief RABBI and head of the SHAS party in ISRAEL RABBI OVADIA YOSEF just died.
THIS is what he said about our PALESTINIANS brothers; [they’re snakes and cursed; wicked ones].
HE also said [it’s forbidden to be merciful to them; and we should send missles to annihilate them].
AND ERIC this what he said about our people when hurricane KATRINA happened; [they are evil and damnable and it was GOD’S wrath against them ; he said GOD said let’s bring a tsunami and drown them].
KEEP in mind the nation of ISRAEL is only 7 million people ;but when he died last OCTOBER 3 million people showed up for his funeral; all the past and present politicians were obligated to be there and show respect.
AND I also have quotes from the ASHENAZI CHIEF RABBI DAVID LAU using derogatory terms describing blacks by referring to us as [KUSHIMS] which is the n- word in ISRAEL.
ERIC the treatment the PALESTINIANS are getting from the JEWS are commanded by their religious beliefs and their politics reflect this when you see and hear their prime minister of ISRAEL[NETANYAHU] who is a politician and a non religious person act and treat the PALESTINIANS in the same way.
ERIC there is no way for you to understand this unless you actually know what JEWS believe.
ERIC I know you from our past engagements and I know you to be a unprincipled man who is willing to use his writing skills to deceive his own people; but I must urge you do not allow the JEWS to use you as a front man for their protection ; let them to fight their own battles.
ERIC go to my blog and find the pictures of RUSSEL SIMMONS and read the article; I posted it as a warning to people like you who don’t do what I do and that is pay attention to JEWS!
http://robertatx.wordpress.com/
@wattree, I love a well thought out rebuttal from an adult. Which part of my comment was idiotic.. I’m result driven and I use past and present human instincts to muddle through the past. Peace treaties you might assume ends wars and that’s about it…a closer look and its essentially a leveragesd debt product for the banks. Like I said I’m result driven, so in my estimation to the spoils go the victor. A country might have more territory, but it ain’t worth ish compared to all the loans it takes to rebuild a war torn city…
To the victor goes the spoils, and so to history is affected. Especially after war and a city’s possessions and power to control of their own narrative are limited. I understand my point of view affects yours and you offer know insight to resolve the conflict, only emotion. You say it can’t be true.
In this game….
Your lookin at the teams effort while I just check the box score. Like I said, I’m results driven.
Everyone remember. When your opponent has no clue they will name call & throw out low hangin fruit… Pause and remember just like knives you are sharp and when your rubbed up against something dull and rough, you actually get sharper.
@wattree thanks for the fruit. Now in the immortal words or MR.Sherman…
U mad bro?
Cicero,
You’re an idiot.
Yocheved,
It worth writing the article just to read your response. We’re on exactly the same page. Thank you.
Thank you for your clarification. I am Jewish, and I also teach my daughter (and anyone else I catch saying something ignorant) is that we judge people by their ACTIONS, and nothing else.
Every Passover, I take the Haggadah as a teachable moment to explain the Civil Rights movement, and why slavery is completely unacceptable in any moment in history. Equality is a BIG thing in my house.
I belong to a Sephardic synagogue, where I am by far the whitest person there! We have Ethiopian, African American, Moroccan, and Temani people, all of various shades of brown. We are all one people! Jew or Gentile, convert or born Jew, all of G-d’s children are beautiful and precious.
Here’s a little known fact (or known, but rarely spoken about), a Jew wrote “Strange Fruit”, and another Jew wrote the music. Yet another Jew promoted the song, and made sure that it got heard in as many venues as possible.
Jewish lawyers donated their time to help Blacks who had been arrested in protests, and many Jews were involved in the Freedom Rides. These are the Jews that we look up to in our family. Social justice benefits all of mankind, and it’s the only G-dly thing to do.
I pray for the day when Black, white, Jew, Muslim, Druze, Bedoin, and everyone else can all show respect for each other. We don’t have to agree, but we should all look for the spark of Divine in each other, and honor that.
Thanks for letting me throw in my “two shekels”. Peace, and Shalom!
The author probably thinks Blacks sold Blacks into slavery. Stop. Quit regurgitating everything from your 6th grade social studies class. Whites have ran all over and through Africa. Post Slavery the European countries carved Africa up like a meal (peacefully too) Google De Beers Diamonds??
So you want readers to believe that the European purchased slaves/resources for full price. He was Holding a GUN ya twerp. Quit thinking the man with the Gun pays full price. LMAO
Reminds of the story of the Lion, Bear, and Wolf. Power is Power and that has never changed throughout history.
Once again we have an old narrative. Swear this sites ran by two white guys and a Jew.
Step 1: Say something or write a sentence that has the word Jew in it… Step 2: Run, Hide, & Spread Panic… Master coming…
Whites, S. Americans, blacks, Asian all have slurs aimed at them but say Jew and the fear is astronomical and comical.
I wish the writer had enough courage to stick to his guns and not buckle under pressure. Nobody knew what your “reader” said… Who cares, but one person says one thing, and we all have to submit to the emotions of Jews?
They do quite well for themselves, they have to have thicker skin. I wish, but Zionism’s philosophy isn’t one of inclusion but exclusion….. paraphrase: Its us God loves.. forget the rest.
Its just like racism (inclusion by exclusion)…white America can say they aren’t racist. Then history, statistics are released, or a murder trial reminds us what America we live in.
I wish the author traveled to Israel, West Bank, to Palestinians… Not saying who’s right or wrong…but nobody loves a one sided argument (don’t rob me of my entertainment in this or any dispute)
Zionism is a philosophy. Racism is too.
But if you were benefiting from it and it never diminished your living standards, you aren’t going to protest and call an end to your benefit. Whites and Jews benefit from the status quo in America. They might say they aren’t or don’t want to… & then proceed to a workplace and not see a soul outside there demographic in their office cubicles…smh
Funny how the NAACP (black people think we created it and run it from top to bottom) Actually created by Jews. They control and frame all Race Debate. But they are so pale….ironic and sad…Assoc. of Colored People ran by those without pigment. No wonder we are losing the war
A broad swipe would have done us just during and possibly after Slavery…running from anything white back then would have been best. Instead of the North, if we had went south or did go south we were better off. Never understood how tropical people would want to run North. That promise of freedom from the north was garbage. Never heard of Mexico returning slaves to America. Has anyone????