Wednesday, January 19, 2022

For Brothas Only: Can We Really Handle Independent Black Women?

Like Love Haha Wow Sad Angry

( We’ve all heard of her; she’s been crooned, immortalized and hyped since the beginning of the 1990’s as the strong, self-sufficient black woman.  She’s appeared in film, literature and theater as the saving grace of the black family and the antidote to black male patriarchy.  In the process, she’s become the star of African American post-modern folklore; there aren’t too many black families that don’t claim her as one of their own.  She is the independent black woman, and when it comes to black men, there are no shades of grey – you either love her or you don’t!

So why are independent sistas feeling a lil hate on the part of black men in an era where we’ve supposedly advanced far enough in gender relations to respect the progress of black women?  Can black men really handle this new breed of sisterhood?    

The attitudes of black men regarding strong, successful black women seem to run the whole gamut – from a grudging acceptance to applause to outright rejection.  Such attitudes persist even in the face of statistics that show a widening gap between how black women and men are faring in the American  economy and otherwise: more black women than men hold degrees; the unemployment rate for brothers is twice that of white men; and, in a recent poll conducted by Millennium Men of Color, only 18% of black male respondents described relationships between the black sexes as “good”.

How do black men deal with a woman who’s been raised to make it without him and how do black women – the ones who really want to love and be loved – reach out to men who feel this way?

Unfortunately, the line of demarcation is usually marked by economics.  It is not sobering that black men and women tend to measure one another by economic means, as opposed to spiritual standards or by more common themes such as family values, work ethic and religious commitment.

There are plenty of brothers who honor and respect a woman who is at the top financially, professionally and spiritually.  Sadly, though, there are far too many brothers who struggle with this reality.  It’s mainly because of how we have been socialized to see ourselves as providers.  We’ve been stripped of that role in a sense, not because women insist on being breadwinners, but because, in most cases, they didn’t have a choice!  Unfortunately, brothers have occupied the bottom rung of the economic ladder when it comes to jobs.  We tend to be the first fired and the last hired; overall, American employers shy away from hiring black men.

As a result of this role reversal, too many brothers either suffer in silence or exhibit hostility toward their more successful counterparts.  Let’s face it brothers, our psyche has taken a beating due to this peculiar American experience. And so our reactions have more to do not with how much our women make, but rather how much we aren’t making in comparison. As a result, we focus on what we don’t want – to be judged by our wallets alone and whether we are financial equals.  We then miss out on what we really want: a loving relationship in which our masculine identities and contributions are valued – what we bring to the table overall.

Add to this the I-don’t-need-a-man revolt that began in the 1990’s and many brothers are feeling the blues when it comes to relationships with successful women.

What we need, brothers, is a new way of thinking. We should attempt to understand that black women, successful or not, are also entangled in a system that has yet to afford them full acceptance in the marketplace.  Not only that, we must accept that – regardless of how we’ve been socialized – times have changed.

Let’s not be locked into dictates just because it’s the way we were raised. Are you really going to toss and turn tonight because a woman offered to pay for dinner?  Are you less a man because she makes more money than you?  My answer: absolutely not!         

Independent black women are here to stay!  And, with the emergence in the last four years of Michelle Obama as the quintessential successful black woman, independent sisters are and will be a force for some time. 

Finally, we need as black men to realize that – politics aside – our women do indeed need us, just like we need them. There are very few black women who do not need – as Stephanie Williams once crooned – ‘the comfort of a man’.  Beneath the thin veneer of financial success, professional acclaim and spiritual bliss is an insatiable need to love and be loved by a man (emphasis on man) who will come correctly. 

Take heart brothers! For every Michelle, there is a Barack!  We can relate to our successful sistas and give them their just desserts.  In doing, so we become models for a generation of men.

Staff Writer; W. Eric Croomes
This talented brother is also founder of a Non-Profit Support Group for Fathers; Their Eyes Were Watching Daddy.
One may also visit his person website at;


52 Responses to “For Brothas Only: Can We Really Handle Independent Black Women?”
  1. This Is Why Many Of Us Good Men Are Still Single Today says:

    The real problem unfortunately is that women in general either black or white that are strong and very independent which they usually have the worst attitude problem and really no good personality as well as no respect for us men the way they’re acting these days with us good men. The ones that are making a six figure income really think that they’re God’s gift to men since many of them which i will admit are making way more money than we do which has really changed them for the worst unfortunately. Many of these women will mouth off to us when we will just say good morning how are you doing which they will be very mean to us and they do feel that we owe them something which is kind of sad for them to act this way which really makes it very difficult for many of us good men that are either black or white. Wow, it is very sad how the women of today that have really changed since the old days when they were so much different back then which made it very easy for our family members finding real love with one another which today unfortunately it is a completely different story. This certainly is the real excellent reason why many of us good men are still single today since it really does take two to tango.

  2. A Black Woman says:

    These comments from black men really breaks my heart. The majority of these comments are filled with hatred of the black woman. Why?? To say that we were created for man is dehumanizing. We are not objects, slaves or property to own. Black men please stop stripping us of human equality!! Why does the black woman deserve less than any other woman? If we have dreams, goals, careers, make more money, we are not good enough for the black man. If we are on welfare, we are not good enough for the black man. When is the demeaning going to stop? Why doesn’t the black woman deserve a black mans love?