(ThyBlackMan.com) Over the weekend I met a Black conservative. I’m not sure if he is a registered Republican, Democrat or Independent but he is by all means a conservative. His family refers to him as “Obama hater.” I thought he was fun to talk to. It’s not often I’m able to spar with a person of my ethnic background but of differing political views. (I long for the day to talk to Herman Cain.) Our conversation, and all his reasons he would not vote for Obama, made me think about the Republican party’s constant overtures toward the Black community. Whether genuine or strictly politically motivated matters not, but their consistency is at the very least admirable.
In 2008 Michael Steele was positioned as the Republican answer to then Senator Obama. In 2010 Republican Allen West was elected to the House representing a South Florida district and a face of the Tea Party. Now in 2012 Allen West faces re-election, Utah’s Mia Love hopes to become the first Black Republican woman elected to the House, and Deneen Borelli is the new outreach director for the Tea Party group, FreedomWorks. Consistency at its best. But is it worth it?
Historically, Blacks voted Republican as the party of Lincoln. Southern Whites voted Democrat and were known as the Dixiecrats. This all changed in the mid 20th century when Civil Rights would not go away and a Democratic President was the first to decide to do something about it. Since then Blacks have voted Democrat, educated Whites have voted Democrat and the Republican party has become the party of the Confederacy and blue collar workers without degrees. A party preserving southern values, evangelism, and money hoarding.
Of the three values Black Americans could hold the key to Republicans winning over minorities. Many Blacks are devoutly religious. Even if as young adults not practicing a specific religion many of us were raised in a church that even in a rebellious state to organized religion we can’t shake the hold of hell and brimstone, damnation and sin. Evangelism is what Black folks are known for. It’s in Negro spirituals still sung today. It’s evident in the broadcasts from the mega churches of T.D. Jakes and Creflo Dollar. The sermons of Juanita Bynum and Marvin Winans.
But for some reason religion and politics don’t mix when it comes to the Republican party. It sounds good; tax cuts, living the American dream by working hard for it instead of taking a handout, not paying a higher load of taxes to take care of those who haven’t reached your level of wealth and affluence and making everyone in the country pull their own weight by eliminating entitlements. But this message doesn’t always resonate in the Black community.
Is it because without a handout we know we would not be where we are today? Or is it because of the few handouts we received we cannot put all of our faith in the White republic; the American dream?
The Supreme Court will soon decide the fate of Affirmative Action in the Fisher v. University of Texas case. The decision could either uphold Affirmative Action or signal its end in a country where opportunities look equal in EOE clauses but are decidedly unequal in the racial make up of board rooms and business offices. Former Republican Presidential Candidate Herman Cain is against affirmative action as is one of the deciding members of the Supreme Court, Clarence Thomas. Both say they reached their level of personal and public success solely on their own merit (and maybe a little bit of nepotism).
While Thomas and Cain’s meritorious success is dubious considering the years of their upbringing, it is naive for them to believe through all the problems this country has been through with race when it comes to getting jobs all’s fair in the market place. Beyond this naivete is proof merit means nothing when race or suspected race is a factor.
Affirmative action is still very much necessary. It is necessary until the moment we stop saying first before modern day Black accomplishments. Take Mia Love for example. She hopes to become the first Black woman Republican ever elected to the U.S. House of Representatives. While she may understate the historic importance of her election in interviews it is no doubt on her mind just as it was on President Obama’s mind when he was elected as the nation’s first Black President. Their stories are American stories. They could only come true in America. But at the same time they have also only been able to come true because of the small steps taken by others before them who endured refusals and lack of acceptance and were only tolerated because the law said so.
Republicans may have started off as the party of Black folks, and they may even win over a few more minorities every year with their hardline message of “do it yourself” and “do it for you and nobody else.” But they must go back to the values that made them appealing in the first place by coupling the message of working hard for the American dream while also recognizing some will need help combatting the ignorance persistent among those who believe by birth right and skin color they are better than another and on that merit alone have the right to take advantage of, steal from, and decline men and women who’d like to do it all on their own but find themselves shut out of ever attaining a reasonable goal.
Staff Writer; Nikesha Leeper
To connect with this sister feel free to visit; Change Comes Slow.
Our problem is we fall for narrative that we are the victim and the dems are the only party that can help us. The dems have been painting us as being the victim for years. It’s a strategy that progressives have mastered over the years. Even though we have a black president, the narrative is still that we are the victim, the system is geared for us to fail and we can’t make it without the help of the dems and the govt. Well since the progressive movement hit the inner cities with their social justice policies ie welfare,free clinics, unions etc, the inner cities have gotten worse. Most of these cities have been run by a dem mayor and city council for over 60 years. Every time they need to fire up potential voters, they pinpoint who they want the victim to be and who they want to demonize ie war on women, war on old people, war on blacks, the rich is the problem, the repubs want dirty water, rich oil companies. They also know how to pull at our heart strings. Anytime the right proposes something, the first thing the dems scream is racism. They can’t cry wolf too much more. 95% of our voters voted for the president. The dems take our vote for granted. The only way to achieve some power in politics is to register independent. That way both parties will have to work to get our vote. Also the author is right about when blacks started switching over to the dems. If you read the Jim Crow laws, it specifically states that blacks could not be in the democrat party. When the equal rights act was signed by LBJ, the dems got the credit since he was the president at the time, even though the republican congress along with civil rights activists were the one that made him crack. The great John Kennedy wouldn’t even sign the bill.
A few things, good column in general. First it wasn’t civil rights in particular which lead to the shift for Black folks. It was the depression and the welfare system put in place by Roosevelt.
The greatest challenge the Republicans face is that they are disconnected from the concept of social justice. YES, Blacks do generally test our on the conservative end of the spectrum when it comes to individual morality BUT based upon our history in this country, we look harder as social morality/justice.
Until the Republican party can legitimately put forth programs that are serious about addressing systemic equality it is likely that they will not see a wholesale change of Blacks voting for them. The challenge is that if they do do that, they will lose chunks of their major voting base. Damned if you do, damned if you don’t.
I disagree with much of what was said by the author. Basically if the GOP was serious about getting blacks to support them they would put forth a real genuine program targeted to blacks only. Something like an enterprises zones with guaranteed capital/business loan financing in black neighbors, this could possible help reduce the high rates of black unemployment.