(ThyBlackMan.com) Can anyone name a movie that came out recently starring a black man who wasn’t a sociopath? Someone who had a terrific screen presence, like a young Paul Robeson? And he portrayed a character who was complex and fully drawn? Did he respect black women, too?
Anybody saw that movie? I didn’t. But surely it’s out there somewhere, right? An alternative to those Tyler Perry films portraying black men as Satan’s gift to black women? But where is it?
Maybe I didn’t hear about it because of all the buzz over Perry’s “For Colored Girls,” which opened Friday and is based on Ntozake Shange’s 1975 stage play, “For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide When the Rainbow is Enuf.”
Or maybe I didn’t hear about it because I was retching too loudly after seeing “For Colored Girls” – and reading so many inexplicably glowing reviews.
“This movie is powerful,” Demetria L. Lucas wrote recently in Essence, the nation’s premier magazine for black women. “It is incredible. The performances in it are astonishing, but most of all, this film will leave you lifted.”
Me, I thought the movie should have renamed: For Black Men Who Have Considered Homicide After Watching Another Perry Movie.
“Oscar buzz, breaking news,” read the Hollywood Reporter on Friday. “Will ‘For Colored Girls’ blindside Tyler Perry’s critics?”
Too late. I was blindsided while watching the movie, especially when superstar Janet Jackson appeared on screen looking like Michael Jackson with breast implants.
“Don’t laugh,” says Shadow and Act, an online publication about black films and filmmakers. ” ‘For Colored Girls,’ an Oscar contender?”
Oscar for what?
In the category for best infection of a black woman with a sexually transmitted disease that renders her infertile. . . . And the winner is: Black man.
For best down-low, double-dealing husband who has sex with wife while sneaking around having sex with men on the streets. . . . And the winner is: Black man.
For best portrayal of a guy who at first seems nice but turns out to be a rapist. . . . And the winner is – OMG, his third of the night – Black man!
“You may need some time alone after viewing ‘For Colored Girls,’ ” wrote Tonya Pendleton for BlackAmericaWeb.com. “Whatever you may think of the fact that it was Tyler Perry who finally brought the award-winning 1974 Ntozake Shange stage production to the big screen, it will move you.”
So will ex-lax.
“You will want to know that two kids get thrown out the window by their father,” wrote Jane Nosonchuk for Hamptonroads.com. “The scene is well done.”
Do I hear another Oscar nomination?
“The men in the movie are all bad guys except for the cop,” Nosonchuk wrote. “They are a means to an end rather than any lead characters. Also, a back-room abortion may disturb some.”
You think?
What an awful year for movies featuring black actors. Samuel L. Jackson in “Unthinkable.” Thoughtless would be more like it. “Brooklyn’s Finest” had a nice cast, with Don Cheadle and Wesley Snipes. But Richard Gere and Ethan Hawke got top billing. “Our Family Wedding” with Forrest Whitaker was okay. But how many black wedding comedies can you watch. Even preacher T.D. Jakes is coming out with his own copycat wedding movie next year.
Surely Spike Lee and Denzel Washington could team up for a sweeping historical drama – say, a black sharecropper’s son, educated in a one-room schoolhouse built by slaves in Alabama, who grows up to become one of Wall Street’s most powerful CEOs.
Smarter than Gordon Gekko, but more complex. With a cameo appearance by former Merrill Lynch chief executive Stanley O’Neal.
Maybe you saw the kind of movie I’m talking about. If not, maybe it’s time to make one.
Written By Courtland Milloy
How ’bout the 20th anniversary re-make of “Thelma And Louise” starring
Yours Trlu in the 2011,late-fiftyish-early sixtyish handsome black cowboy
equivalent of Brad Pitt’s sensitive stud character?(I’m 57-58 July 6,and said to look 15-20 years younger by a lot of the local-Windsor,Ont.,Can. ladies.)
Of course,THAT ISN’T ABOUT TO HAPPEN because white AND BLACK HOLLYWOOD are afraid of handsome black men who eschew the dapper,”ultra-urban,” silky smooth “brotha” who just can’t resist a “sista,” no matter who fat,fugly,frigid or b***hy,and who,like me,are suburban or exurban cowboys who are into heavy metal,garage rock,Country music,dancing-EXCEPT LINE DANCING!!!-rodeo-non-existent here in my Windsor,Ont.,Can. birth-place and home-town,though I AVIDLY watch it on TV-casual,sometimes Western garb and buxom blondes and Latinas between 24 and 42.(Plus,they couldn’t relate to a black man with a genius-level IQ-mine is between 147-160-CHARLES MURRAY,SHOVE YOUR RACIST “BELL CURVE” PIECE OF CRAP UP YOUR BLOATED,BIGOTED,TEA PARTY-LOVING A**!!!)Right or wrong,folks?
I am a Black female and I absolutely agree with the men on this one. I am sick and tired of Tyler Perry. I am not a hopeless woman with a Black man beating and abusing me all of the time. Have I experienced trauma at the hands of a man before? Yes, but that does not define who I am. Do men also feel hurt and pain? Yes, but we would not know if we do not stop to hear what they have to say.
Tyler Perry films has a recurring theme: The hopeless black woman and the belligerent black man. I’m tired of his movies, themes, and inaccurate depictions of Black men and women. He needs to sit down.
I started off by simply reading the article but could not help but comment. As a Black woman, I am trying my hardest to understand why so many of us support his movies, when they depict us in the most helpless way. Why do we feed into his drama? Haven’t we come further than that? Shouldn’t we celebrate our accomplishments and the accomplishments of our men? Furthermore, I was dismayed at the fact that the sisters who posted hardly took the time to actually wait and see what the brothers had to say. They are hurting just like we hurt! They experience pain just like we feel! But more importantly, they are strong and resilient and they should be depicted as strong men with character.
As a single Black mother, I know what it feels like to be both mom and dad… Having to console my son, lay down the law, and be leader for my household. I do not by any means claim to know what it’s like to be a Black father, but I can only imagine, as the single parenting experience has opened my eyes to how both single moms and dads must feel. It is a humbling experience.
I usually just read a few of the articles on this site, as I find the authors to be inspiring. But I had to comment on this one. There are some sisters who feel the same way many of our brothers feel on this one. And not only do we recognize the need for more positive Black male images in film and media, we whole-heartedly support it!
Black Men need to stop supporting Buffoonery. This transvestite was abused by a man, while the women in his life sat back and watched. This makes them both responsible. It’s enough blame to go around as to why descent movies are not being made. The problem I have with Tyler Perry is, just like he was preyed upon. He is now doing the same thing to women. He is only exploiting Black Women/ Men and making them look like idiots in the eyes of the public. This man does not have your best interest in mind nor is he trying to help the structure of the Black family. “Black Men do not support this movie BOYCOTT this one.”
Black women do not have a monopoly on pain. Why can’t we see the pain of mental illness that led one of the characters to kill his children? Why can’t we see the pain of the man who was to ashamed to admit, even to himself, what he was? Why do we stoke ourselves in the pain of black women and pretend black men have none? We are all feeling human beings except no one wants to hear the black mans feelings. And then we wonder why some act like sociopaths.
i get so sick of the “film about the experience of black women reaction from black men” that we can ALWAYS count on. it is so old and so tired now. perhaps if there were not so many victims of rape, incest, molestation, and abandonment in the african-american community perpetrated by black men, there would be fewer movies covering the subject. if you want to write, produce, and direct a film about a sharecropper’s son turned CEO, you are as free to do so as anyone else to do so. if you want to elist spike and denzel, please do so. why you seem completely blind to the good men in tyler perry’s movies,i’m not sure. there is always one in the role of prince charming who shows the black woman that they do exist, and another one played by perry himself who is the long suffering husband of a drug addicted wife who has abandoned him and his children, but i don’t see how you would know that if you, like so many of his critics, choose not to see his films. artistic people tend to write from their experience. if that experience is pain, that is what they write. and the people to whom that pain resonates, they support them.
perhaps you are one of the fortunates who has never been victimized by a man. i congratulate you. but i resent your resentment of the films that represent the collective experience of the rest of us. (and please explain why you found it necessary to personally attack the appearance of janet jackson while criticizing the theme of the work?) and if you would care to get in touch with the pain that compels mr. perry to explore the topics he does, perhaps you should tune in to oprah this friday as she tackles the taboo subject of men who have been the victim of sexual abuse, by – dare i say it – other men.
rather than attack the art that pain creates, perhaps you and all those like you, should spend more time attacking the pain that creates the art. perhaps then, there will be less of both.
Despite what u think of the movie those situations are reality for many women. if nothing else this movie can let them know they are not alone and there is a way out. and if you are unhappy with how reality is portrayed in today’s films by all means step up and start making your own. show us YOUR reality.