(ThyBlackMan.com) As an undergraduate I wrote a senior thesis entitled “The Myth of the Black Quarterback,” where-in I concluded that Black athletes, and specifically Black quarterbacks, have constantly had to fight with the racial “demons” of the past. Namely, their success has often fallen victim to the struggle to transcend an “intellectually inferior” stigma. The rise of Denver Broncos Quarterback Tim Tebow is evidence that this exploitation and discrediting of Black quarterbacks and their alleged mental ineptness persists, as the creation of a grossly overlooked double standard.
Historically, Black athletes have been worshipped – as physical specimen – for their superhuman abilities, which is often perceived as far superior to their White counterparts. Their limitations only extended as far as their incapacity to play positions like quarterback or to be head coaches. These were thinking positions requiring intelligence beyond what many believed to be within the bounds of Black intelligence. In the shadows of this assertion, every Black quarterback since Marlin Briscoe – who in 1968 ironically became the first Black quarterback to start in the National Football League for the Denver Broncos – has struggled to overcome the stereotype.
Conversely, Tim Tebow has received admiration for winning games, despite inconsistent play and meager statistics. In the past, Michael Vick faced similar criticism; he had a strong arm but had failed to develop the accuracy and precision required of a traditional quarterback. Vick was too one-dimensional. And, his speed and unpredictability were more of a crutch than a competitive advantage.
Under such chastisement, Black quarterbacks are forced into conformity as pocket passers or risk being remembered as gimmicks rather than a step forward in the evolution of the position. And yet, Tim Tebow popularity as a hybrid quarterback is an inherent testament to the likes of Briscoe, Randall Cunningham, Warren Moon, Donovan McNabb,and Michael Vick – recognition that remains largely absent.
Finish story over at; UrbanCusp – Tim Tebow Black QB’s, etc.
Also follow UrbanCusp on Twitter; http://twitter.com/UrbanCusp/.
and Facebook; http://www.facebook.com/urbancusp.
One of the main problems today with black QB’s is the Black sportscaster. I asked this question once on-line, when Cam was finishing his career at Auburn, if we only changed CAM NEWTON skin color to white, leave everything else about his life and stats the same….what would the white sportscaster be saying? I think that he (Cam) would have been hailed by white sportscasters and white bloggers and NFL scouts as the next coming of Jesus. But the problem is we already know how the white media operates. The sad part of this thing is how the black media operates, meaning the black sportscasters like Irving, Sanders, Sapp, Faulk, Dukes and the others. These guys allow white sports casters to marginalize Cam Newteon and RGIII while putting white QB’s that can’t even tie their shoes on a pedestal. Not one of them have ever said Cam is a great QB. They give a description that is appeasing to white’s, pay attention.
If a white QB had done what Cam did those black sportscasters would be singing their praises and would not be afraid to call them great, you know why because the white sportscasters would be calling them great. Change Cam skin color to white and ask yourself what would the NFL scouts be saying about Cam this,his 2nd upcoming NFL season, I bet it would not be about no sophomore jinks. Think I’m kidding…when have you heard them talk about Jake Locker sophomore jinks, this would give the black sportscasters permission to say the same. Because it appears the black sportscasters need permission or approval from whites to say a black QB is great. White sportscasters always call white QB’s great even before they have ever played a game in the NFL, if the white end up being a bust, they whites don’t care, they just pick the next white B to call great. It is about time our black sportscasters do the same for our black QB’s. Let me give you an example and I could give you 50 more if I had the time. A black sportscaster was talking and the white sportscaster was listening and agreeing. The black sportscaster said they need to give RGIII just some of the playbook so as not to rush him, the white sportscasters shook his head in agreement, but when that same black sportscaster said the same thing about Andrew Luck the white sportscaster maid sure to say the Colt’s need to give Luck the entire playbook. Now RGIII graduated in 3 years from Baylor and was on the deans list at least 2 of those years. These whites are letting these black sportscasters demean our black QB’s so they can say it’s not us and they, black sportscaster, don’t even get it. Like I said I can name you 50 more of these instances.
I would agree with ALL WHO POSTED; (It’s not a black-n-white issue anymore; now it’s about $$$$$$$$$$$$$$; always was & always will be: (Take note of the current themes being splattered all over the media and it’s not the race issue at hand but; how much race can be used in the political arena b4 somebody goes to jail)…… Regardless of the QB’s race; ALL QB’s will be put under the scope however, it is sad that INTELLIGENCE is not the main priority to be an NFL QB. Cam is very smart; and I applaud him for his character in handling all the critics who can only put their foot in their mouths now yet, I don’t see Tebow going the same route that Newton did and, my main issue with Tebow is that he; just like any other QB drafted; has to learn the mechanics of the position.
I may be off the issue on this but, this is just how I see this media mess with Black QB’s, as compared to Whit QB’s.
Didn’t claim Tebow is rookie. I was responding to this part: “Much is made about Tebow’s rushing ability but Newton is the record holder for rushing touchdowns by a QB and leads the entire league in rushing td,s plus he has a 60% completion rating.”
I was with you on Cam being rookie of the year, remember?
Daredevil Tebow is not a rookie. Cam is also on pace to break the rookie passing yards, Peyton Manning holds that record currently. My point is not to dispute what Tebow is doing but to point out that I hear a few white sportscasters arguing that Dalton is NFL Rookie of the year.
Black athletes have always gotten the short end of the stick no matter what position they play. This is sloooowly changing but too many brothers don’t help themselves when they live up to the ghetto stereo types on and off the field/court. They seem to never understand that this is what many whites want to see in order to prove their racist philiosphies.
Tebow is ahead of both Cam and Andy Dalton in passer rating at 87.
Tebow leads the NFL for those with 70 or more rushes in average per rush. No lead quarterbacks merely in rushing average. But lead everyone including the tailbacks.
PS: I believe Cam Newton (other son of a preacher man) is rookie of the year. And I want both him and Tebow to succeed. Can’t help it- I’m a Gator, and Cam will always be a Gator to me.
This will open the flood gates for black qb’s to the NFL. Every team will now have to get a stud qb in order to be successful.
I have noticed that some white sports commentators, specifically Terry Bradshaw, have been lobbying to give Andy Dalton NFL Rookie of the year because his team, the Bengals are 7-5 and ignoring the record setting play of Carolina’s Cam Newton because the team is 4-8. Despite the fact that the award is for individual play and not a team award. Much is made about Tebow’s rushing ability but Newton is the record holder for rushing touchdowns by a QB and leads the entire league in rushing td,s plus he has a 60% completion rating and a higher QB rating than Andy Dalton thus far.
I have been waiting for this racial angle to come out in the media. The more success he has, the more of this we will see, rightly or wrongly. What the author is failing to see is the fact Tebow will be forced to conform also, eventually. Not this year, but you can already see how the coaches and media pundits are shrieking for him to ‘prove’ he can play in the pocket. So it is no different for him than for the great black quarterbacks who preceded him. I do not believe this is a black white issue, although there are some common themes. It is true running qbs have been forced into the pocket in the nfl, but it is also true Tebow will have to do the same, or be cast aside. Thats a fact. Unless he can prove it is viable, then maybe he will pave the way for qbs of any color to run or throw as they see fit.
You haven’t seen the Randall Cunningham video then.
http://www.kwgn.com/news/kdvr-randall-cunningham-tim-tebow-divinely-appointed-20111209,0,2331702.story
Tebow’s stats are not meager where they count the most: 4th quarter qb rating and comebacks, first among qbs in regards to TD to int ratio and first in league among those with at least 70 rushes in yards per carry. And Randall Cunningham would disagree with your claim he hasn’t perform as well.