American-Israeli Politics: Where Bullying is Called Self-Defense. : ThyBlackMan

Wednesday, September 26, 2018

American-Israeli Politics: Where Bullying is Called Self-Defense.

July 23, 2014 by  
Filed under News, Opinion, Politics, Weekly Columns

Like Love Haha Wow Sad Angry

( “And I stand shoulder to shoulder with Israel as it defends itself against this shocking violence.” Senator Cory Booker

“Israel is entitled to take the steps necessary to protect itself from destructive rocket attacks from Hamas that are aimed at all Israeli civilians, regardless of their religion,” said Senator Charles Schumer

“We support Israel’s right to self-defense.” Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton

It was General William Tecumseh Sherman, whom after conducting his devastating campaign against Georgia’s civilian population and burning the city of Atlanta, who said, “War is Hell.” This statement is likely the most concise and appropriate description of war recorded in modern history since the publication of Carl von Clausewitz‘s great military-theoretical classic On War published in the 1873.  I despise war and the carnage it results in regardless of the factions involved. But what is next in line that I personally find as upsetting, is the cosmetic over simplification used by many, often the oppressor in these exercise, to sanitize what isoil-2014 barbaric brutality in its purest form.

The recent re-start of the incessant military engagement between Israel and Gaza (one that has been going on since 1949), has reared its ugly head again. And as usual, the result is the same, the mass slaughter of mostly innocent civilians, mainly women and children, which outside of newspeak, resembles ethnic cleansing more than a military engagement. However, as noted in the opening quotes, it is the retro chic position of the moment to describe Israel’s actions as SELF-DEFENSE. This misappropriation of the term SELF-DEFENSE defeats reason, logic and any operational definition used in the past to define this action.

By definition, a noun, self-defense refers to the use of reasonable force to protect oneself or members of the family from bodily harm from the attack of an aggressor, if the defender has reason to believe they are in danger. Consequently, the force used in self-defense may be sufficient for protection from said perceived harm such to stop any danger from attack, but cannot be an excuse to continue the attack or the use of excessive force. Thus self-defense cannot include killing or great bodily harm to defend property or collective forms of punishment.

The present actions of the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) do not meet any of the aforementioned operational definitions.  Even under the purview of Just War Theory”, which asserts military personnel must take careful aim at his military target and away from nonmilitary targets, and one cannot kill civilians simply because he finds them between himself and his enemies. Simply not to intend the deaths of civilians is not the pragmatic objective in this sense, but rather paramount is to save civilian lives even if it means risking soldiers’ lives.

What is obviated from the discussion is that self-defense means that if the people of a nation are suffering aggression, oppression, or genocide, and are themselves capable of stopping it, they are morally entitled to respond militarily.  Unfortunately Israel cannot claim this position, given that aggression from another nation can only be described in self-defense if it is a last resort, which historically we hasn’t been the case (2012, 2008, etc.). In addition, the self-defense notion under the assumption of military action being a last resort cannot be met also because every other conceivable avenue outside of using military force has not been tried. Moreover, the kidnaping and murder of three innocent individuals, usually a police action cannot be perceived as a last resort or the impetus to start aggressive military action. But when these standards are not met, the result is Gaza: an innocent populous is the victim of a catastrophic attack

Another point of contention is that self-defense is virtuous and practical. What Israel is practicing is more like a George Zimmerman style of self-defense. Instead of self-defense, the actions of Israel are more akin to bullying. Bullying is unwanted, aggressive behavior that involves a real or perceived power imbalance. The behavior is repeated, or has the potential to be repeated, over time. Bullies intend to harm their targets and usually are continuous and sustained. This means that they (bullies) target their victims multiple times, frequently with the same act over and over. More importantly is that the bully intends to harm the target.

I say this because the assertion of self-defense avoids the historical reality of colonial occupation of Gaza by Israel which prevents effort on behalf of the Palestinians living in what has been described as an open air prison, the ability and human right to establish a proper, free society. If Israel was trying to avoid civilian deaths, they would and could, but this is not their desire. They are possessed with an evil dogma of annihilation similar to that we saw in South Africa during apartheid. Their objective is to destroy and kill all who are in the way of their imperialistic desire to control and occupy all of Gaza, inclusive of it rich natural gas and oil reserves. For example, it is a well-known fact that The IDF calculates the number of calories Gaza’s civilian population needs to just survive on a daily basis and transports foods into Gaza accordingly. This is not self-defense, it is bullying with the objective to occupy territory accordingly break up the will and lands of the Palestinian people. Ironically, it closely the plan of Adolf Eichmann, the architect of ethnic cleansing, for Hitler. And anyone that cannot accept this, I’m cool, but facts are facts: Soweto 1976 is no different than Gaza 2014.

Since the 1990s, Israel has repeatedly failed to meet and even broke all of the conditions outlined in documented agreements with both parties.  They continue to play this shell game that gives them the privilege to ignore the natural human rights that Palestinians have like all other peoples in the world.  There is an aggression of the worse kind: one that indicates they will always be against a two-state solution, while knowing this is what the majority of Palestinians have agreed with and desire. They should just admit they desire to ethnic cleanse Gaza, and take thier oil and natural gas. 

Staff Writer; Torrance Stephens 
For more articles by this talented brother do visit; Raw Dawg Buffalo.


3 Responses to “American-Israeli Politics: Where Bullying is Called Self-Defense.”
  1. Steve says:

    You either forgot or strategically left out the reality that Egypt also participates in the blockade against Gaza. Truly another Arab nation isn’t interested in the annihilation of its own people. On top of that if Israel wanted to eliminate Gaza and the West Bank it could do so easily. Lastly it had been proven time and time again that HAMAS attributes all their losses as civilians. Why aren’t there any reports of fighter casualties? According to them all fatalities are women, children, and civilians. It doesn’t make any sense that in war only non combatants are counted as casualties. The truth is no other Arab nation truly wants to take up the cause of the Palestinian people. If so then why hasn’t Jordan, Lebanon or Egypt wholesale opened their borders to fleeing Palestinians?

  2. Jeff Stath says:

    Mr. Stephens,
    We have a wonderful freedom of speech in the US, but I take issue with your course of thinking and dismiss it out of hand as being naive and misinformed. When all one does is repeat what one has heard, spoken of by others, which, in a Court of law, would be classified as hearsay, I suggest you come over here to southern Israel and live for months under the present rocket attack. I am a Viet Nam Veteran and am doing just that. Come stand here with me, then write what is truth, not just hearsay.
    It’s sad when the UN itself, denied repeatedly, the existence of weapons in the form of rockets being stored at its facilities in Gaza. Then, on the day before the Israeli offensive, they not only admitted to to above, but turned the stored rockets back over to Hamas.
    In truth, The goal of Hamas is the eradication of the state of Israel. By firing thousands of rockets into israeli civilian population centers, which by the way is a War Crime, they, by their own admission, have declared WAR on Israel.
    Israel, with the same right the US had in WWII, has only reacted as the US did after Japan attacked Pearl Harbor, they started fighting back.
    Jeff Stath,
    Beer Sheva Israel

  3. ROBERT says:

    IT’S good to know in the age of OBAMA that some of us has maintained their principles and morality also kept the lessons of our ancestors lives; because we are required by our history to come to the aid of the weak and helpless.

    AS we watch this vicious bloodletting being conducted by the SATANIC JEWS upon a virtually defenseless population essentially shooting fish in a barrel with the worlds most sophisticated weapons and then witnessing the first black POTUS and other officials stand by them should make all OBAMA’S supporters look in the mirror and ask themselves was it worth it!

    NO one likes to admit they were fooled and the easy thing to do is what the OBAMA supporters have been doing is to act like it’s not happening but it is and the whole world is watching!

Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!