Tuesday, July 14, 2020

Thy GOP & African-Americans: The Way Forward.

January 28, 2013 by  
Filed under News, Opinion, Politics, Weekly Columns

Like Love Haha Wow Sad Angry

(ThyBlackMan.com) Dr. Milton Friedman, as one of the pre-eminent fiscal conservatives of the 20th century, was perhaps also one of the most eloquent voices in support of libertarian values as moral values. Alongside Dr. Walter Williams, Dr. Thomas Sowell, and others, Friedman opposed programs like affirmative action, minimum wage laws, and welfare. All three were also strong opponents of government restrictions on school choice.

At its core, these beliefs came from two sources. Firstly, they stemmed from a recognition of the history of unintended consequences of “progressive” liberal policies intended to support the disenfranchised, and African Americans in particular. They argued that affirmative action failed to address the core challenges of Black employment. Instead, they pointed out to a direct correlation between the implementation of minimum wage laws, and the rise of black youth unemployment; without being able to pay unskilled workers at a rate that accurately represented their capacity to contribute to the firm, they were effectively “frozen out” of the job market, rather than being able to choose to start at a lower rate, and then learn the valuable on the job training that would empower them to demand higher wages in the future. Instead, they find themselves doubly trapped—being supplied with an inferior government Black-Republican education system, without being allowed the means to pursue other alternatives, and then again being refused the opportunity to supplement this education with on the job training.

The government welfare initiatives, they argued, further compounded the malaise. If human action is governed by incentives, and if good governments are those who provide a society of positive incentives that create responsible, productive citizens, then what would the effects be of offering more earning potential from a welfare system than from applying for an entry level position in the job market? The consequences, of course, was actually what was to be expected—one more disincentive to equipped African Americans and other disenfranchised groups with the skills training required to progressively demand higher and higher earning power in the free market. Expressed and expanded upon in a wealth of critically acclaimed literature and academia, these core ideas formed the underpinning of the Republican agenda for African Americans ever since.

Looking at moving away from traditional welfare systems with the passing of the 1992 Republican Congress’s welfare reform legislation, the steady rise in African American per capita GDP, and the success of numerous school choice programs in raising academic achievements across all ranges of African American socio-economic brackets—why is there still the continued belief in the mainstream media and the Black community that the Republican party and its ideals have “failed” African Americans?

Some of it, clearly, is out of pure ignorance. For Kanye West to suggest that “George Bush hates black people,” when President Bush has saved more lives in Africa than any other President in American history, is simply nonsense.

At the heart of such notions is the idea that the Republican party is somehow oblivious or opposed to the best interests of African Americans and other minorities—from allegations of the Tea Party being a racist institution (despite supporting the political rises of numerous African American candidates), to claims by media personalities like MSNBC’s Chris Hayes that “It is undeniably the case that racist Americans are almost entirely in one political coalition and not the other.”

One of the key kernels of this notion sprang from the Goldwater refusal to categorically support the civil rights act of 1964. Goldwater did so not out of a support of racism—he was one of the leading advocates for civil rights himself—but out of a fundamental belief in the unconstitutional authority of the government to dictate morality. As the argument was laid out by Friedman in 1962 in his work, Capitalism and Freedom:

Is there any difference in principle between the taste that leads a householder to prefer an attractive servant to an ugly one and the taste that leads another to prefer a Negro to a white or a white to a Negro, except that we sympathize and agree with the one taste and may not agree with the other? I do not mean to say that all tastes are equally good. On the contrary, I believe strongly that the color of a man’s skin or the religion of his parents is, by itself, no reason to treat him differently; that a man should be judged by what he is and what he does and not by these external characteristics. I deplore what seem to me the prejudice and narrowness of outlook of those whose tastes differ from mine in this respect and I think less of them for it. But in a society based on free discussion, the appropriate recourse is for me to seek to persuade them that their tastes are bad and that they should change their views and their behavior, not to use coercive power to enforce my tastes and my attitudes on others.

It’s obvious that such an argument is not coming from a place of hatred of racial intolerance. Nevertheless, the optics of a presidential candidate opposing what was felt to be the necessary means to end Jim Crow held profound ramifications for the resultant exodus of Blacks from the Republican Party.

It is crucial to realize that this exodus was not the result of Barry Goldwater taking a principled if controversial stand in support of his libertarian values. His true failure came from an inability of the campaign, and the party as a whole, to present a viable, attractive alternative to end the Jim Crow era capable of gaining widespread support. In not doing so, the Democrats were allowed to paint themselves as the lone defenders of the interests of African Americans—an article of faith liberals have attempted to ingrain into the national conscious ever since.

In many ways, this is the same challenge that Libertarianism and the Republican Party is faced with today. As a party focused on personal liberty, and especially focused on, as Martin Luther King aspired, to “judging a man not by the color of his skin but by the content of his character,” developing any kind of “racial agenda” has often been viewed as something of an anathema to the worldview of most modern Republicans. Much like Goldwater, however, despite expressing a noble, laudable, and sincere principle, such positions are inadequate when they are not accompanied by an alternative series of policies capable of addressing these same specific challenges in a way that is both adequate and capable of winning large scale public support.

Boiled to its essence—the Republican Party can no longer afford to be silent on the specific issues unique to the African American community, nor to lack a systematic, proven policy for addressing the urban issues of the nation.

In theory, this shouldn’t actually be a particularly difficult agenda to pursue. After all, given the near monopoly Democrats have had in many major urban centers to improve the lives of African Americans over the last 40 years—how much can be said for their track record? In particular, it’s worth noting that some of the most significant roadblocks to overcoming poverty in urban black communities are precisely the sorts of things libertarians like Friedman warned against. From failed schools, to crime ridden public housing projects, to intergenerational poverty traps, to egregiously high levels of black youth unemployment, a disproportionately high number of socioeconomic challenges today are the result of misguided government policies—specifically, misguided Democratic policies.

Consider that out of the top ten US cities with the highest poverty rate in the nation, all ten are governed by Democratic leaders. The ten poorest performers among America’s 50 largest school districts? All led by Democrats.

Similar rankings on crime, urban decay, failing infrastructure and public transport all point overwhelmingly to the same conclusion. What’s more, all of these failings have disproportionately influenced African Americans. In Democrat governed Detroit, the eleventh largest school district in the nation, Black dropout rates approach an unprecedented 80%. In Democrat led Washington DC, HIV rates among African Americans hover over 3%–surpassing Somalia, Sudan, Ghana, Ethiopia, and several other third world African nations—only slightly surpassed by the Republic of the Congo.

Among the 25 most dangerous cities in America for violent crime (again, disproportionately effective low income black urban communities), not one of the failed cities were governed by a Republican.

Given such consistent records of lackluster leadership, it becomes a wonder of modern marketing that the Democratic Party has managed to brand itself as a party of responsible stewardship for the Black community. It’s an even more amazing failure of modern marketing that the Republicans haven’t wiped the failed urban Democratic brand off the map by shining a massive spotlight on their history of dismal leadership, while offering up attractive, systematic alternatives with proven track records.

The opportunities to compete and win back the African American community are very real. Dissatisfaction with the status quo is palpable. Our values—access to on the job training, expanding options for quality education, and eliminating incentive structures that reinforce intergenerational poverty—equip us with the intellectual framework we need to be able to institute effective long term change. But in the same way that many African Americans were well aware of Lyndon Johnson’s questionable track record on civil rights prior to 1964, this uncertainty and openness to new alternatives will only be relevant if Republicans are capable of offering up clear, attractive, specific solutions to the challenges faced in modern Black communities—in a way that we were unable to offer to the ending of segregation.

Written By Andrew Simon

Official website; http://www.hiphoprepublican.com

For more thought provoking articles visit; HipHopRepublican.com.

Also connect with them via twitter; http://twitter.com/HHR



6 Responses to “Thy GOP & African-Americans: The Way Forward.”
  1. Ramses says:

    You know what nix that….your response says everything I need to know…your site has given me everything I needed…lol….thanks…lol

  2. Ramses says:

    oh so we telling on adults now? lol you have my IP address? what does that mean? Address the issue if you have one. Don’t hide your hate. State your case if you have one. Let’s air out your gripe towards me and let’s show these people why you allow white folks to say what they want on here yet you have a problem with my content when you don’t have any disclaimer on here where you limit what people can say which would be more limiting than a white person? Don’t say I can’t give my views when you have never seen me attacked anyone personaly, yet you see white folks on here get personal as well as blacks with each other and all types of stuff, yet you single me out. So state your beef. Unless you’re scared then I’d be coll cause at least that’s honest. Don’t hide behind black women. State your issue, whether you be man or woman but I believe it’s the owner who is a man. Or male rather. Sound scared to me

  3. Staff says:

    One more comment like that, and you will be ban.
    And yes I have your IP, etc.

  4. Ramses says:

    LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL!!!!! @Thyblackman STAFF….what a bunch of losers…. what a bunch of cowards….especially the dudes…..a bunch of of male brawds…..”you’re gonna stop bashing black women.” LOLOLOL…you know what’s so funny? I have seen some white folks who have gotten on here and blasted black people. And I never once saw you cowards cut off the comment sections. You niggas are a freaking joke. You let white folks come on here and say whatever they want and say nothing but a black man speak the truth to your homo asses, with your weak ass degrees, spewing psycho babble, and you shook. You degenerate monkeys better be glad I don’t run this place because you would try to immigrate to Mexico for real. Bitch niggas really do discuss me and one thing i would agree with: black women aren’t the problem at all. It’s the hoe ass black men that’s the problem. Weak in the knees for real. I’m glad you finally showed your true colors cause you niggas scared of me because even though you don’t like what I say, you won’t say it to me directly. To hell with you niggas and your slave lineages and I’ll be sure not to marry a black woman so that you could never be my brother-in-law because if I had to look at you niggas to fight a war, I’ll be better off surrendering for real. Bitch made ass niggas for real. Broke ass slave niggas for real. Credit score probably 400. LOL…and I know how to clean credit too. LOL!!!! Have you at 850. LOL!!!! But i’ll never show you niggas how to get money. Keep writing your weak ass theses and keep begging the white man for weak ass teacher jobs where you only make 30,000 a year publishing bullshit like Michael Eric Dyson. But while you niggas beg for pussy from weak brawds, I’ll make sure I send you a postcard from Argentina with me and that bad Latina sitting on the beach why you slaving in his companies. I won’t hire your asses for real. I’ll employ Mexicans before I hire you clowns. So don’t worry about me talking about black women because the black man of america is the true enemy of black people because he is commercially incompetent, and emotionally too weak to his woman in place. Hell he can’t even call his woman his woman the way she acts nowadays. Good riddance weak ass cowards. I was waiting on you niggas who own the site to address me directly in front of everyone on here and as usual, you bitch up. Scared to challenge me on your own site. You do the equivalent of what black women do when they don’t want to hear what black man has to say: hang up the phone. Instead of hanging up the phone, you cut off the comment section!!!! Now I see why me an black women have not gotten along> When they saw me, they saw weak niggas like you, no matter what was given to them. On that note, i express a little bit more mercy towards them. With weak men like you niggas, the don’t have a prayer for survival. I would suggest the few decent black women left to go outside the group instead of dealing with these faggots. I’m definitely going out the group getting mine. To hell with these losers. Bet you weak niggas never thought you would hear a black man suggesting to black women to date outside the group. Let’s you know how i think of you weaklings. “please stop bashing our black queens!!!!!!!!!!!!” Lol fucking cry babies!!!!!! lol

  5. I hear what you are saying liberal, repub, or dem if your interest was in helping urban America, Negro was never acceptable, you argument on Goldwater, was Goldwaters, history has it place. While leaving history in the past you are correct on one thing the past 40 years has been unprogressive for urban communities, yes the dem. represent urban areas, and it has been denied representation. But I trully wonder why if you say it’s not racism, if you feel the dem. leaders do not need you help, or you will not help because they are seperate. I think our politcians, all involved has less interest in seriously helping urban Communities unless they control. It is thought and felt that education, and other information valuable has been limited for a seeminly racism bia judicial, legeslative event house or senate function creating wealth the name of the party or politician often has not mattered. When a person can not tell the truth, dislike people enough to slander and abuse via ‘N’egect America’s middle class tax and insentatives to support stablizing and rebuilding American thur ethnic and ethical needed in urban communities, not gentrification a racist and abusive process. Stepping up literally you know the problems, stop trying to win talking it up. The people you are talking about are not deaf and ignorant. This is America We love it and all bipartisan work is taken seriously, and feel you then are working in the interest of Americans not race and corporate americas interest.

Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!